It seems like there is an overload of online handmade marketplaces lately. We all know
Etsy and
DaWanda, but now there's
Shop Handmade,
ArtFire,
Folksy,
1000 Markets,
Coriandr, and probably loads more that I haven't heard of. Not to mention individual seller websites! How does one decide where to sell?
Personally, I have had the most success on DaWanda. I read in DaWanda's literature that most of their page views come from Germany, which definitely works in my favor. I can list my items in German, which means German customers are more likely to find me. I can also offer inexpensive and fast shipping to customers within Germany.
I have also had some success on Etsy, but not nearly equal to that on DaWanda. There are so many people selling there that it is hard for potential customers to find you. Many sellers relist their items to keep them at the top of the search results, but my sales there aren't enough to justify spending the extra money to do that. Another thing working against me on Etsy is shipping costs. It costs me about €6 ($8) to ship to the US. Not many people would want to pay that for a few cards, myself included! I will continue to list on Etsy, especially since they have recently added Google Analytics functionality, but most of my efforts will be concentrated on DaWanda.
I'm also currently selling on ArtFire. I love what they are going for - no selling fees, artisan guilds, and built-in analytics. So far, the views have been low and I haven't had any sales. I will probably only update listings every other month or so, but I really hope the site takes off.
I'm also working on my own personal website with shopping cart. This is my ultimate goal as it allows me complete control over analytics, currencies, design, advertising, etc.
I tried Shop Handmade, but didn't care for their seller interface. I do like that they donate proceeds to environmental causes, but because of the lack of views/sales, I decided that it was not worth the effort.
As a seller, it is crucial to figure out which selling venues are the most beneficial to you. It can take hours and hours setting up a shop at some of these venues, only to find out it wasn't worth the time and effort. What are your thoughts on this handmade overload? Where do you sell? Where have you had success? What factors do you measure when deciding if a selling venue is worth your time and effort?